Home » Newcomer Director Rescues ‘A Quiet Place: Day One’ After Exit

Michael Sarnoski Took Over ‘A Quiet Place: Day One’ After Jeff Nichols Exited

By

–

Newcomer Director Rescues A Quiet Place: Day One After Exit

“Start over. Do what you want to do.” That, by Michael Sarnoski’s account, was the message waiting for him when he took over “A Quiet Place: Day One” from Jeff Nichols. Nichols and franchise co-creator John Krasinski had been working on a script. Sarnoski said he got a blank page instead.

“I needed that,” he told The Hollywood Reporter. “I didn’t want to have to adjust stuff that already existed.”

How a Pig director got the job

Sarnoski’s one feature before this was the 2021 drama “Pig,” with Nicolas Cage as a reclusive truffle forager. Krasinski watched it and reached out. By Sarnoski’s telling, the pitch was a question: what would happen if he brought some of that “Pig” touch to the Quiet Place universe? The Hollywood Reporter said Nichols left over creative differences with Krasinski. Collider described the parting as amicable.

Sarnoski had been dodging big studio films on purpose. He said an indie director moving to a studio picture had become “a little bit of a trope.” Krasinski’s pitch got past that, he said, because it came with freedom: “We want a different vision in this universe so that all of these movies don’t start feeling the same.” He also credited Nichols with a “very sweet hand-off,” and called him “an amazing director.”

The prompt itself was narrow. Krasinski wanted a New York City story set on the first day of the invasion, an idea seeded by a line from Djimon Hounsou’s character in “A Quiet Place Part II,” Collider reported. Sarnoski’s way in was a character, Sam, played by Lupita Nyong’o.

A heroine who is not trying to survive

Sam is a poet in hospice care, dying when the world ends. During a group outing to a marionette show in Lower Manhattan, she and her cat, Frodo, run into the sound-hunting creatures as a meteor shower brings them down. They survive the first wave and break away from the hospice group. Along the way they meet Eric, a young British law student played by Joseph Quinn, who does not want to be alone at the end of the world.

Sarnoski said he set out to dodge the usual disaster-movie tropes, such as fighting the creatures, escaping the city or rescuing someone. “What if my main character wasn’t even really trying to survive at the end of the day?” he said. Frodo was not meant as a nod to the pig in his earlier film. He had planned a break from animals, he said, but a sick woman walking a cat through a wrecked New York kept pulling him back.

Nyong’o, he told Collider, was wary of cats when shooting began. By the end she loved them and owns one now.

Premiere and reception

The film premiered in New York on June 26, 2024, tied to the Tribeca Festival. Because of that late premiere, the review embargo lifted the day after, which had some online commentators suspecting studio nerves. Sarnoski said that was not the reason. The Hollywood Reporter put its opening weekend at $53 million, a franchise record, with strong reviews.

Sarnoski’s next film is “The Death of Robin Hood,” with Hugh Jackman and Jodie Comer.

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

Celebrity

Movies & TV

Music

Streaming