Home » How Connie Britton Uses ‘Phony’ to Explore the Uncharted Realities of Modern Motherhood

How Connie Britton Uses ‘Phony’ to Explore the Uncharted Realities of Modern Motherhood

By

–

How Connie Britton Uses 'Phony' to Explore the Uncharted Realities of Modern Motherhood

Sonny Cooke swerves to dodge a fallen tree on his way to meet his girlfriend and drives straight into Bucket Pond, where a sign already marks the many deaths there. A week later he wakes from a coma and looks at his mother, and does not know her.

That is the setup for “Phony,” the Hulu comedy-mystery that premiered on October 20. Connie Britton plays Ellen Cooke, a single mother and high school principal. Sam Nivola is Sonny, convinced the woman at his bedside is an imposter. The show was created by Nick Paley.

A metaphor that hits home

Britton, 59, told PEOPLE the premise struck her at once. “I was thinking, ‘This is such an amazing metaphor for what happens between a parent and their child during the teenage years,’” she said. “Because of course it’s a teenager’s job to, like, separate. But it’s so painful, and the way that teenagers go about it is so hard. And I’m experiencing my version of that.”

Her son, Yoby, is now 15. She adopted him from Ethiopia in November 2011, when he was 9 months old, after a three-year process. In a PEOPLE cover story she described raising him as a single mother, and recalled 18-hour days on Nashville with no “support system.”

She has long been “TV’s favorite mom,” thanks to Tami Taylor in Friday Night Lights, even while feeling “clueless” about motherhood. One day she was in her trailer, panicking before a scene in which Tami talks to her daughter about sex. “This is probably exactly what it feels like to be a mother: You have no idea what you’re doing,” she remembers thinking. Now, she says, “you basically wake up every day and have no freaking idea what you’re doing. And I’m a single mom doing it myself, so I’ve just got to figure it out. There is no guidebook.”

On Watch What Happens Live in January 2021, she explained why she adopted. Both her parents had died within three years, and she was not in a relationship heading toward marriage. “What am I waiting for?” she asked herself. It turned out to be “a really hard thing to do,” she said, but she would encourage anyone to try.

Inside the town

A reviewer who watched the first four of eight episodes calls the series a mystery with the “beating heart of a high school dramedy,” closer in temperament to Freaks & Geeks than Stranger Things. It plays out in a mountainous slice of the small-town Pacific Northwest, with the Canadian tax breaks that draw American productions north, and the landscape pressing in on all sides. A reference to Lewis & Clark College hints at Oregon.

Ellen and Sonny are unusually close. There is no father in the picture, nor is one mentioned, and Sonny roams the halls of Delby High as a kind of unofficial lieutenant to his mother. That closeness is what makes his suspicion sting. The reviewer found the change in Britton’s familiar face just off enough to be creepy, and notes that Sonny’s symptoms mirror Capgras syndrome, which nobody in the show names.

Sonny’s friend Weldon, played by Colter Lee, takes the story seriously and puts him in touch with Sharla, a private investigator played by Meera Syal. “I know what it’s like to be called crazy,” she tells him, “but all you really need is one person to believe you.”

Sources

Photo: angela n. from Washington, DC (CC BY 2.0)

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

Celebrity

Movies & TV

Music

Streaming